There are kids whom sit and play, talking with one another about a "sweet" new video game they have been wasting their time playing. There are kids whom do the homework that they were to lazy/tired (life is very stressful at New Trier) the night before. There are kids who sleep the period away as a time to let loose and catch up on the sleep they were deprived of the night before (me). Yet the ones I noticed most clearly were the ones that I sit, not too coincidentally, right in the midst of.
If I had to brand this group of young men, I believe that I would use the word ambitious, which in many ways can be slightly misgiving as I would probably define ambition as something much different from the characteristic that these boys exhibit.
Every morning they sit and talk about one subject, and one subject alone. That is college. It is all about college.
Now it is hard to imagine so much time being spent on one subject, I understand the confusion, but believe me it is possible. Here are some of the ludicrous topics that I endure:
- High School Course Selection - This is my favorite, every morning a discussion starts up as to what classes college will look favorably upon. It is commonly held that only the most rigorous courses, based completely on how much you can memorize of a textbook, will truly get colleges on board. This conversation slowly shifts from a question posed, to a facetious assault on all those that choose not to slowly and painfully kill themselves with textbook readings every night.
- Where to Go? - This really is the most interesting, as it is at the heart of the topic. Any school that is not dressed in reigns of ivy is considered taboo, and kids who truly do not want to have any association with such an institution are instantly shunned, only to be brought back into the conversation, being allowed only to apologize to the group by rescinding their comment. One morning I hinted that I would really enjoy going to the University of California at Berkeley. The first response that I got was a snicker, and then a comment I will never forget, "that hippy playground? That school is for people that have no aim in life!". Little judgements such as this are things that really stick in the heads of those so fortunate as to have them directed in their general direction.
- What to Study? - A subject that slowly becomes more gruesome as the years go by, exactly what people want to go to school for is slowly ripped apart by those that deem it as lesser than their own personal choices. There is always an air of superiority about when this topic is discussed. It is a literal breeding ground for exceptionalism, and it is almost painful to be a part of. If anyone were to even suggest a major that is not considered academic, such as I did one day entertaining the idea of becoming a singer, they would instantly be chastised through harsh insults until their only option was to repent to the socially created gods become of the so-called future business majors.
Because this is America, right? One size fits all, you need to go to school and get a degree or else you will be considered a second class citizen. It all boils down to efficiency, you are supposed to strive to become the most productive person you can be (this is not a bad idea, given that productive is not given such a narrow meaning).
I believe that these odd occurrences are evidence of a lingering mentality, an almost overly patriotic sentiment that has been evidenced during very perilous times. When the private sector boomed as part of the war effort and everyone was supposed to either become a factory worker or a valiant war fighter.
In the midst of a huge economic recession I fear that we are falling back into this trend of emphasis on efficiency that breeds an overly patriotic sentiment, yet I still do not understand what it gets us. In an ever changing world, we should be emphasizing diversity, not cookie cutter lifestyles. What does it all get us?
I'm sorry to hear that you endure such abuse every day. That really must be trying. In the end, your teachers and college counselor will tell you to study what YOU want to study, and go to school where YOU want to go. About efficiency, I think it is a good thing. It helps our economy. Getting a job that pays good money allows you to support yourself comfortably. But that doesn't mean that you even have to go to college. Some of the most economically successful people in the world were college dropouts. Then again, what is success? If you consider happiness success, then some of the most successful people may never have even gone to college, nor will we probably ever hear about them. So, in the end, society wants us to think that going through the system will in some way make us happy. But that is for the individual to decide. For some, it might. Others might choose a different path. In the end, it is your decision.
ReplyDeleteI completely understand what you are saying. I have started looking for colleges some myself, and it is a very difficult process. For me, I not only struggle with the academic side of things, I also struggle with the athletic side. If I even think about bringing up a Division III school to my coach, he berates me incessantly for even considering such an option. I'm supposed to be a competitive tennis player, so I should be playing for the best Division I schools possible. The same thing goes at home as well. I am actually afraid to mention to my parents any schools that aren't top notch. If they accept anyone with an ACT score below a 30 I can just throw that option right out the window because I know that all I will hear from my parents is "you can do better than that honey, why would you want to go there?" So my inner struggle to be comfortable with the college selection process continues. As for the whole idea of being productive in America, I think we all strive to be the most productive we can be. However, we’re always looking for more, to be even better. I remember one time when my brother came into my room and asked me if a B was a good grade in a level 3 class at New Trier. I tried to brush off the subject and told him that he should just try to do the best he could do and if he was satisfied with the grade then that’s all that mattered. But he wanted more. He asked me if working hard and getting Cs was good, if doing well just meant working hard. At that point, I just said point blank, “Alex, there’s no shame in doing your best, but sometimes the world requires a little bit more.” I still remember those exact words and I actually have them written down on a piece of paper and pinned to the door of my room. I am constantly reminded that in order to be successful in this world, you need to not only work hard, but work smart, grab opportunities when you can, and always plan and set up for future success. Basically, I think that’s what the boys in your advisory are saying to you when they pick on you for not wanting an Ivy League school or wanting to major in something other than quantum physics. I personally am not saying there is anything wrong with your own choices, because they are probably made with purpose, but I am saying that I do believe there is a higher standard set for everybody, so high that it’s nearly impossible to reach.
ReplyDeleteAlthough I can easily relate to the conversations you overhear, as I'm sure most of us could, I am rather confused by the last bit of your post.
ReplyDeleteWhat is this "overly patriotic sentiment?" What does college have to do with it?
How can a time of economic boom and urging people to work hard in manual labor produce the same effect as an economic recession and urging people to reach almost impossible goals in schooling?
I can understand some confusion as to this point, and it is an important distinction that you make. The way that I view it is that people are trying to return to times that were not as, "perilous", as they are now. This patriotic, almost hopeful nostalgia is a driving force behind the seemingly unconquerable expectations that are put on us. To everyone else, thank you for your input!
ReplyDeleteJon, this is easily one of the best posts I have read so far. I have the same feeling about other classmates talking about colleges, and those 3 points and the way you explained them were just awesome. I couldn't agree more. Bravo!
ReplyDeleteHi Jon,
ReplyDeleteI very much enjoyed your style of writing, but I have to agree with Hayley in that some of this is simply hard to understand. Try to privilege clarity over style and make your points more directly.
When you say, "It all boils down to efficiency, you are supposed to strive to become the most productive person you can be", what evidence do you really provide? Is there some kind of article or other piece of writing you can link to?
Keep in mind that going to college is a means toward social class mobility, so those you are criticize are not completely groundless in their concerns.